I took a bit of a risk a month or two ago and bought a used Canon EOS 1Ds Mk2 on Ebay. I did have my reservations about the condition and quality before it arrived. I was however very pleasantly surprised. It came with three batteries and a small camera bag. More importantly, it was in very good condition – so I was pleased.
The reason I had for buying is that I wanted another full frame Digital SLR (I already own a Canon 5DMk2) so the lenses I use on a shoot or wedding day have the same effective focal length. My thought process was that if this camera’s quality, which is now obsolete, was of the highest quality 2 or 3 years ago then why should it not be good enough now? I have to say that I have not been disappointed and the differences (between it and the 5D) are only visible under the closest of inspections.
A couple of weeks ago however, I thought my rather clever theory had come undone. In the middle of photographing a wedding in Henley the shutter on the 1Ds failed – one of the blades stuck leaving big thick black rectangles across the image. This was spotted immediately due to the error message on the display. The problem, I thought, had corrected itself after a bit of fiddling but I couldn’t risk carrying on using the 1Ds so I switched to my back up Canon 50D. That day I had four cameras at the wedding so there is never any danger of a wedding being ruined by equipment loss or failure. My caution was rewarded as I noticed the next day that the test shots I had taken after the failure had in actual fact a lot of over exposed ghosting across the images – phew!
I have now had the shutter fixed by Canon and it is as good as new though I am £200 lighter. I still have great deal of confidence in the camera and shall carry on using it as much as my 5D. Having said this though, I will never attend a wedding with only one camera – Imagine having to explain that your one and only camera has packed up, it doesn’t bear thinking about does it!!??
Anyway, failures aside, I think the quality is excellent – even now! I guess you have to ask yourself why should you take the hit on depreciation when you consider that I paid 20% of the original cost of the camera and that includes the repair. Can you tell the difference? Have a look at the gallery below, there are 8 images from a wedding – four taken on the 1Ds and four on the 5D Mk2, but which are which?
This slideshow requires JavaScript.